In the vast world of sports card collecting, the concept of grading has become a cornerstone that determines the value, authenticity, and desirability of collectible cards. With the sports memorabilia market reaching unprecedented heights, understanding the ins and outs of sports card grading is crucial for collectors aiming to make informed decisions. This comprehensive guide delves into the essence of card grading, providing insights into the process, major grading services, and the profound impact grading has on card value.
The Basics of Sports Card Grading
What is Card Grading?
Card grading is the process of evaluating sports cards based on their condition and authenticity, resulting in a graded score that reflects their overall quality. This meticulous assessment covers factors such as corners, edges, surface, and centering, along with the card’s authenticity. Graded cards are then encapsulated in tamper-proof slabs, ensuring their protection and preserving their condition over time. The primary purpose of card grading is to provide a standardized measure of a card’s condition, enhancing its marketability and collector appeal.
Grading Scales Explained
Grading services employ a numerical scale, typically ranging from 1 to 10, with 10 representing a card in pristine condition. Two of the most recognized grading companies, Professional Sports Authenticator (PSA) and Beckett Grading Services (BGS), use slightly different scales and criteria to assess cards. PSA’s grading scale is widely accepted as the industry standard, while BGS adds complexity by offering subgrades for corners, centering, edges, and surface. These subgrades provide a more detailed analysis of the card’s condition, appealing to collectors who seek granular insights into their collectibles.
There are some differences between the grading scales used by PSA and BGS to evaluate the condition of a card. Both grading systems use a 10-point scale, with grades ranging from “Gem Mint 10” to “Poor 1”, and half-point markers for near-mint cards (8.5). However, PSA does not issue a 9.5 grade like BGS does. Instead, PSA uses the term “Gem Mint 10” to refer to their grade 10 cards, which is the same as BGS’s “Gem Mint 9.5” grade. BGS less frequently issues grade 10 ratings, which they call “Pristine 10”; if all subgrades correlate however, it may get the “black label” version of Gem Mint 10, which BGS flagships as the perfect conditioned card.
Collectors alike consider a PSA 10 and a BGS 10 to be close to the same, but pricing can be very different. As you can see below, we have a PSA 10, BGS 10, and a BGS 10 “Black label” Shohei Ohtani Topps Chrome rookie baseball card. As you can see they all look quite different on the slab with the black label BGS having perfect sub grades, and the PSA Gem mint 10 having no subgrades.
Major Grading Services Overview
Professional Sports Authenticator (PSA)
PSA is perhaps the most renowned name in the sports card grading industry, known for its stringent grading standards and the high value attributed to its graded cards. Collectors trust PSA for its consistency and the premium it can add to card values. A PSA grade is often seen as a benchmark for card quality, influencing both buyer confidence and the card’s market value.
Beckett Grading Services (BGS)
Beckett, another titan in the card grading realm, offers a unique proposition with its subgrade system, providing a detailed breakdown of the card’s attributes. This level of detail caters to collectors who appreciate a comprehensive analysis of their cards. BGS grades are particularly valued in the market for modern cards, where minute differences in condition can significantly impact overall value.
Other Grading Services
While PSA and BGS dominate the landscape, other reputable services like SGC (Sports Card Guaranty) and CGC (Certified Guaranty Company) also offer quality grading services. I will add a small caveat however; the parent company of PSA did just buy the rights to SGC. Moreover, CGC and SGC each have its strengths, with SGC known for its expertise in vintage cards and CGC making strides in modern collectibles. Choosing the right grading service often depends on the specific card, its era, and the collector’s preferences.
The Grading Process
How to Submit Cards for Grading?
Submitting cards for grading involves several steps, starting with selecting cards that are in good condition and likely to receive high grades. Most submitters grab a 10x magnifier and review their cards for corner damage, pits, scratches, etc. Good rule of thumb is, if you can see a flaw, don’t send it in for grading. This term is usually generated towards newer age cards however, 40 years and newer. Vintage cards however, Pre-1980s, can have significant value, even with minor flaws. Collectors must then prepare their submissions, following the specific guidelines provided by the grading service, which often include filling out submission forms and securely packaging the cards. Understanding the fees, turnaround times, and shipping options is crucial to ensure a smooth grading process.
The Impact of Grading on Card Value
Grading can significantly enhance a card’s value, especially for high-grade examples. Cards graded by reputable services like PSA or BGS command higher prices in the market due to the perceived assurance of their condition and authenticity. This section of the guide would benefit from real-life case studies, demonstrating how grading has transformed the value of specific cards, and highlighting the importance of grading in the sports card investment landscape.
The Impact of Grading on Card Value (Cont.)
Case Studies of Graded Cards
To illustrate the tangible benefits of card grading, consider the case of a 1952 Topps Mickey Mantle card. Ungraded, a card of this nature might fetch a significant sum, but once graded by PSA and receiving a mid-grade, its value can skyrocket into the millions. Another modern example involves a 2018 Luka Dončić Panini Prizm Rookie card. Initially valued at a few hundred dollars, a PSA 10 (Gem Mint) grade can elevate its market price substantially, showcasing grading’s impact on both vintage and contemporary cards. Below is a brief example of a raw Michael Jordan 1988 Fleer card(ungraded), a near mint 8(graded), and a gem mint 10(graded) selling prices. As you can see, quality grades significantly affect the cards value.
When to Get a Card Graded
Deciding when to get a card graded involves weighing the cost of grading against the potential increase in value. Cards that are in excellent condition, rare, or have significant sentimental value are prime candidates for grading. Additionally, cards of rising stars or established legends during peak market interest periods offer strategic opportunities for grading. Collectors should consider factors such as the card’s condition, market trends, and grading costs to make informed decisions. A little research on your card will essentially gift you the answer of “should I get it graded” vs. “should I not get it graded”. If the Michael Jordan card above is any consideration, these are the prime examples of cards to get graded due to the substantial value increase potential.
Challenges and Controversies in Card Grading
Despite its many benefits, the card grading industry is not without its challenges and controversies. Issues with grading consistency and subjectivity have been points of contention. For example, collectors have raised concerns about the same card receiving different grades upon resubmission, highlighting potential inconsistencies in the grading process. Moreover, controversies surrounding altered cards slipping through the grading process have sparked debates on authentication methods and quality control, emphasizing the need for transparency and trust in grading services.
The Future of Card Grading
The future of card grading looks promising, with technological advancements poised to enhance accuracy and consistency. Innovations such as AI and machine learning could revolutionize the grading process, providing more objective and precise assessments of card conditions. Additionally, as the collector base grows globally, the demand for grading services is expected to increase, potentially leading to the emergence of new players in the grading market and the evolution of grading standards to meet diverse collector needs.
Conclusion
Graded sports cards occupy a pivotal role in the collectibles market, offering a blend of authenticity, condition verification, and value enhancement that appeals to collectors and investors alike. While navigating the grading process can be complex, understanding the intricacies of different grading services, recognizing the right moments to grade, and staying informed about industry developments can lead to rewarding outcomes for those in the sports card community.
Rookie Sports Card is reader-supported. When you buy through the links outside of our website, we may earn an affiliate commission from Ebay and Amazon.
Article Credits: (2023, Burgess, E. Cardbase)
As always, thank you for your support!